Skip to main content
Ratehub logo
Ratehub logo

Should I pay down my mortgage with a lump sum, or invest?

We break down the numbers

This post was originally published on August 23, 2023. It was last updated on October 29, 2026.

What’s the best way for a homeowner to put a windfall to work? Two beneficial options are making a lump sum payment on your mortgage, or chasing returns by investing the funds.

Which approach will actually put you ahead financially? Let’s take a look at a few possible outcomes for a borrower with an extra $100,000 on hand.

Making a lump sum payment

What is a lump sum payment

A lump sum payment is a mortgage prepayment option for loans with closed terms. It allows you to make a one-time payment up to a certain percentage of your mortgage principal, usually between 10% and 20% annually. Not all mortgage products offer this option; certain “no frill” mortgages may not allow any kind of prepayment.

What’s the benefit of making a lump sum payment on a mortgage?

A lump sum payment reduces the principal portion of your loan, the amount of time it takes to pay down your mortgage and how much interest you’ll pay. 

It can also reduce your monthly payment if your mortgage provider is willing to recalculate it based on your new balance. (This is typically easier to do at renewal.) That lower payment frees up cash flow, which you can save or invest. 

Also read: How much interest would you pay on a 90-year mortgage?

Investing in a passive-income investment such as a GIC 

What is a GIC?

A guaranteed investment certificate (GIC) is a financial instrument that provides a guaranteed return in interest at the end of a set term (typically between one to five years).

Why invest in a GIC?

GICs are extremely low risk, as borrowers invest their money with a federally-regulated financial institution where the deposits are backed by the Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation. Your initial investment will always be returned, unlike with a stock or crypto purchase.

At time of writing, the best five-year GIC in Canada had a return of 4.5%.

Is it better to pay off my mortgage or invest right now?

Let’s run a few comparisons to see which option comes out ahead. We’ll use the following scenario, which assumes a mortgage borrower:

  • Has a mortgage balance of $500,000
  • Signed at a rate of 4.34% (the lowest fixed mortgage rate at time of writing)
  • Is entering a new five-year term
  • Can make up to a 20% lump sum payment

Option 1: They use the $100,000 windfall to reduce their monthly payment and invest the savings each month into an investment vehicle that allows monthly contributions and pays a rate of return of 4.5%.

Option 2: They put the entire $100,000 into a five-year GIC with a rate of 4.5%.

Scenario 1: A low 5-year fixed rate vs. a five-year GIC

5-year fixed mortgage rate of 4.34% and 5-year GIC of 4.5% (compounded annually)

  Lump sum payment made (lower the monthly payment and invest the savings) Invested the $100,000 and kept monthly payment the same    
Mortgage amount $400,000 $500,000    
Remaining amortization 20 years 20 years    
Monthly payment $2,488 $3,110    
Total paid over 5 years $149,273 $186,592    
Remaining balance after 5 years $329,576 $411,970    
Balance lower by $82,394 $0    
Total investment value after 5 years $22 per month at 4.50% = $41,667 $100,000 at 4.50% interest = $124,618    
Total money after 5 years $124,061 $124,618    

In this scenario, it’s a bit of a wash. The difference in money available at the end of the five-year term is $557 higher for the GIC option.

If the investments are held outside a registered investment account, like an RRSP or TFSA, you’ll have to pay taxes on the earnings, too. That will change the calculation.

Check out the best current mortgage rates

Take 2 minutes to answer a few questions and discover the lowest rates available

Scenario 2: Increasing the mortgage rate

5-year fixed mortgage rate of 5.09% and 5-year GIC of 4.5% (compounded annually*)

  Lump sum payment made (lower the monthly payment and invest the savings) Invested the $100,000 and kept monthly payment the same
Mortgage amount $400,000 $500,000
Remaining amortization 20 years 20 years
Monthly payment $2,648 $3,310
Total paid over 5 years $158,878 $198,598
Remaining balance after 5 years $334,039 $417,548
Balance lower by $83,510 $0
Investment value after 5 years $662per month at 4.50% = $44,348 $100,000 at 4.50% = $124,618
Total money after 5 years $127,858 $124,618

This time, making a lump sum comes out ahead by $3,240, not accounting for taxes. The advantage here is scaling back the monthly payment on a mortgage with a higher interest rate.

Scenario 3: Upping the risk factor for higher returns

Let’s say our theoretical borrower has a higher tolerance for risk, and wishes to invest in stocks with a 7% annual return.

5-year fixed mortgage rate of 4.34% and stock market returns of 7%

  Lump sum payment made (lower the monthly payment and invest the savings) Invested the $100,000 and kept monthly payment the same
Mortgage amount $400,000 $500,000
Remaining amortization 20 years 20 years
Monthly payment $2,488 $3,110
Total paid over 5 years $149,273

 

$186,592
Remaining balance after 5 years $329,576 $411,970
Balance lower by $82,394 $0
Investment value after 5 years $622 per month at 7.0% = $44,282 $100,000 at 7% = $140,255
Total money after 5 years $127,858 $124,618

In this case, investing the entire $100,000 at 7% would net you a return $13,579 higher than if you had made the lump sum payment. Higher returns like that will be more tax-advantaged if they are invested using a registered account.

Lump sum payment or investing: How to choose?

When you’re a homeowner with a mortgage, there is no easy answer when choosing how to handle a windfall. In the examples above, the difference in returns between scenarios was negligible — until the extra cash was invested in the stock market and exposed to heightened risk.

As with all investment decisions, what you ultimately do has to align with your risk tolerance, understanding of investment vehicles and cash flow needs. 

Cash flow can’t be overlooked as a benefit here. Paying down your mortgage and freeing up cash each month could help you cover rising daily expenses or an emergency without having to take on additional debt. You don’t have to invest every extra penny to get value out of paying down your mortgage with a lump sum.

Other ways to pay off your mortgage faster

You can also accelerate paying down your mortgage by increasing your regular payment. 

Every dollar you add to your payment goes directly toward paying down the principal. Depending on your lender, you may be able to increase your payment by 15% up to 100% to pay down your mortgage faster.

It also helps to make sure you have the lowest mortgage rate possible. The less interest you pay, the faster you can pay off your mortgage. Comparing mortgage rates online, contacting a mortgage broker and negotiating with your lender can all help secure you a lower rate.

Also read:

Clay Jarvis, Mortgage Expert

Clay Jarvis has spent more than a decade writing about personal finance, the Canadian real estate market and mortgages, most notably as the former editor of Mortgage Broker News. His commentary on housing and general economic issues has been quoted by the Globe & Mail, the Financial Post, CBC and Global News.